16
May
06

no token mother’s day

tromboneMy mother’s day was one of mixed emotion. I had plans to write a long post about the invaluable work of mothers in this world, and I was going to write a couple of letters in support of working mothers. But as much as i tried, i just wasn’t able to write. You see, this mother woke up to find one my babies dead. Trombone, the dwarf hampster to the right, was found curled up in his food bowl. When i went to wake him up and put him in a warmer spot, i found that he wasn’t just sleeping.

I spent awhile yesterday writing a eulogy for Trombone, but i’ve decided not to print it. Instead, i will just say that i’ll miss him and that i am thankful to have had him in my life.

I do still want to say something about mothers, though. I spent a lot of time yesterday thinking about what motherhood means. I talked to my own mother and to one of my best friends (who is a new mother) and i came to realize that motherhood is not a product, its a process. Mothers are not neatly packaged. Their role does not end when a meal is cooked or when the laundry is done. Those acts, the acts that the government Mother’s Day tells us we should be thankful for, are not what make a mother a mother. Moms are educators, organizers, rabble-rousers, breadwinners, and so much more. The friend i mentioned above is a community organizer in the US Southwest. She told me about going back to work and carrying E, the baby, along with her as she went door-to-door talking to people in the community. I talked on the phone with my mom about a variety of topics, one of which was the socialization of violence. These aren’t extraordinary moms. Sure, they are both beautiful, passionate, and dedicated moms, but they are the epitome of motherhood. They aren’t just caretakers, they are actively involved in the process of mothering. They are there every day to support, talk with, cry with, laugh with, and just be with their children.

I was recently re-reading the book Men’s Work by Paul Kivel. In the book, Kivel talks about how you don’t have to have biologically fathered a child to be a father. You don’t even have to adopt a child to be a father. He stated that all men are fathers at different points in their lives. He explained that we must not only recognize the many ways that we are fathers to others, but also in what ways we are acting as father. He was essentially arguing that we need to be actively and critically involved in that process of fathering.

As a genderQueer, and one who hopes to adopt one day, i often think about motherhood and fatherhood and what their respectively gendered roles mean. And there is no shortage of people who find out that i want to adopt and immediately proceed to ask “well, will you let your child call you mother or father?” (Asked as if they have just thrown you the ultimate question to knock you off of the genderQueer fence.) Partly because of my lack of real life model for positive fatherhood, i tend to identify more as a mother to the animals in my life. But that is not merely because i feed, clean, and otherwise care for them. No. I take an active role in their lives. Sure, there’s not a whole lot i can do as far as education, but i sure do some rabble-rousing and organizing.

The animals in my life provide an unmeasurable amount of inspiration in my life. When i think of their stories and look at them, i know that my role as a mother cannot simply stop after feeding time. Lets look at Trombone. Trombone came into my life last year. I was at a friend’s house when we received a call explaining that Trombone was in the back of a pet store awaiting his sentance of death by freezer and wondering if either of us would care for him if he were to escape from prison. Any animal lib kid is well-aware of what we call vegan guilt. Well, of course we said yes (even though there were already a dozen animals between the two houses). And thus began Trombone’s life as a liberated political prisoner.

His story is nothing unique. Pet shops kill countless kittens, puppies, mice, rats, ferrets, bunnies, hampsters, guinea pigs, birds and other animals every day. Most either burn them alive in an incinerator or (more common) stick them in a freezer alive. With puppies, kittens, and sometimes other animals, they don’t do the dirty work themselves. They send them back to the breeder from wence they came (usually because they’ve passed the ’sellable’ age of eight weeks) and it is there that they are killed. If not killed, then sold to a rendering plant where they are killed and turned into food for dogs, cats, cows, pigs, etc. As a mother, i cannot stand by knowing what is going on in the world and do nothing. So i fight against puppy mills, breeders, pet stores that sell animals, rendering plants, and so on.

Tom the Turtle is another animal that lives with me. She is a red-earred slider who was found by a friend about 14 years ago in a bucket of chemicals. Tom’s eyes were burned out of her head and she must now be hand-fed twice a day. How can i sit on my ass while corporations are polluting our world with toxic substances that disable and kill our children everyday?

And the last one i’ll mention is Osil. I try not to take favorites, but i admit, she is my most loved. She has gotten me through some tough times. Osil is a dog. I found her in a ditch over two years ago. She was a four-week-old puppy covered in mud and yelling at a couple of turkeys. I found her early one morning while sitting outside the school in Oventic, Chiapas, Mexico - Autonomous Zapatista Territory. Who we assume is her sister was found a few days before. We were asked to take them. If we did not, they would have died. Not that they Tzotzil people of Oventic are ruthless people, quite the contrary. But they are poor. In fact, some of the poorest people in Mexico. Through the acts of the Zapatistas and their collective organizing, they have done incredibly inspiring things over the past twelve years - started an autonomous school system based on popular education models, a wimmin’s art collective, an organic seed bank, collective farms, a boot company, and more. But economically speaking, they are still among the poorest of the poor. Most cannot afford to feed themselves, let alone another animal. The few dogs they do have in Oventic are large dogs used for protection against invading military and paramilitary forces (however, i must say they aren’t very good at training ruthless guard dogs. The extent to the protective services that i witnessed was that one of them pee’d on my backpack upon my arrival. And then licked my hand. As if to say, “That’s for the colonization. And that’s for the solidarity.” Besides, i never once saw so much as a fence or a chain for these dogs. Not that i’m complaining. My understanding is that the caretakers recognize enslavement as enslavement.) Osil reminds me on a daily basis of the necessary and beautiful struggle of the Zapatistas. The people of Oventic referred to them as “zapatista puppies”. Can i sit idly by knowing that the people of Osil’s homeland are being massacred, starved, beaten, and imprisoned? No. I take the words of Subcommandante Marcos to heart, “we are all zapatistas.”

So this Mother’s Day, i was challenged not to think of the surface work of mothers. I thought of all the work of mothers. The work that Mother’s Day for Peace was originally about. I thought about radical moms, moms on welfare, sex worker moms, single moms, moms of soldiers, soldier moms, moms in prison, majority world moms, second shift moms, moms in struggle, you know, everyday moms. Let’s show some real appreciation for moms. Don’t give flowers, give yourself to a better tomorrow.

Wow, this really isn’t what i planned to write when i sat down. But sometime you just gotta let the mind wander.

[?]
Share This

8 Responses to “no token mother’s day”


  1. 1 brownfemipower May 16th, 2006 at 7:52 am

    vegan, this was so beautiful. i’m so sorry for your loss. i know when my cat died i was devistated. I am so sorry that you had to wake up to that. I am thankful that she got to die surrounded by your protection and not by freezing to death.

    I think you point to a very big concept here–that the role of mothering allows people to finally find a way to look at how to world is interconnected–that is mothering provides a lens that we can look through to figure out ways to improve the world. The role of fathering is currently be reclaimed, but i don’t see the same possibilities there…

    i hope you right more about your visit to mexico–

  2. 2 douglass May 17th, 2006 at 6:52 am

    Vegankid:

    It sucks when that happens!!

    My condolences.

    Now, I posted my final comment on ally work, BEFORE I saw you had commented!!!

    It’s a pity, that was a pithy comment.

    I will get back to you on that shortly, and will check out Paulo Freire’s Pedagogy of the Oppressed or Education for Critical Consciousness. I thought Paul Kivel’s essay was interesting,

    I already said this to IP, but essentially I am a total nazi about having means that are as noble if not nobler than the goals. Otherwise, in the long run, what you said here will unfold: ““What we’ll do, is simply build the same oppressive shit, but call it something new”.

  3. 3 spotted elephant May 17th, 2006 at 9:49 am

    I’m so sorry about Trombone. And I hope that no one reacts badly. It seems there are so many people who discount animals, and there’s also a group who think that if the animal is anything besides a dog or cat, they don’t matter.

    I’d be very happy if every pet store went out of business. And I’m not fond of breeders either.

    Your comments on mothers worldwide were wonderful.

  4. 4 vegankid May 17th, 2006 at 12:23 pm

    thanks, yall.

    bfp - i do believe that mothering is a lens that can be used to help create a better world. But i still think there is some work to be done to challenge some of the socialization around motherhood. Which is what i meant by saying that motherhood is a process and not a product.

    i’v been thinking a lot about the reclamation of fatherhood, but i’ll be honest, i don’t know what that looks like. What is the role of ‘fathers’? I mean, outside of the role of motherhood? While i gained some insight reading Men’s Work, i can’t really see a difference between motherhood and the reclaimed fatherhood. Maybe my gender dysphoric brain is just getting too muddled with questions of gender.

    You know, i entered the blogosphere while i was in Mexico. I would go to an internet cafe in San Cristobal and write my thoughts and reflections on being in zapatista territory. But i think i only wrote three posts and then i blew up the blog… and didn’t return for two years! I don’t think i can get into the same headspace that i was in two and a half years ago, but i would really like to write about what i’ve learned from the Zapatistas - they are such an inspiring model for what i want to create. So perhaps you’ll see some entries soon.

    douglass - ha! we keep missing each other. i just commented over at Ally Work regarding your last post. Basically, i said i hope that it is not your final post on Ally Work. Though i do think it may be time to start up a post on another topic since we were starting to get pretty unfocused. I did really appreciate the dialogue, though. FYI, Pedagogy of the Oppressed is probably a better first read. The other one is more of an annotated outline of the literacy project.

    Ah, the old means and ends discussion. There’s a headache:) But i do agree that we need to really focus on means. So perhaps that is a discussion that we should have someday. I’m a much bigger fan of brainstorming ideas than i am of simply theorizing. And talking about means is a good way to start talking about action.

  5. 5 IrrationalPoint May 18th, 2006 at 3:54 am

    Sorry to hear about Trombone.

    “i can’t really see a difference between motherhood and the reclaimed fatherhood. Maybe my gender dysphoric brain is just getting too muddled with questions of gender.”

    An interesting question. I suspect anyone who isn’t muddled up with questions of gender is muddled up with questions of gender roles :)

    Vegan and Douglass:

    “Ah, the old means and ends discussion. There’s a headache:) But i do agree that we need to really focus on means. So perhaps that is a discussion that we should have someday. I’m a much bigger fan of brainstorming ideas than i am of simply theorizing. And talking about means is a good way to start talking about action.”

    Right on. I look forward to that discussion.

    IP

  6. 6 brownfemipower May 18th, 2006 at 11:05 am

    I mean, outside of the role of motherhood? While i gained some insight reading Men’s Work, i can’t really see a difference between motherhood and the reclaimed fatherhood. Maybe my gender dysphoric brain is just getting too muddled with questions of gender

    i’m not sure i’m getting what your asking here–so let me say what i meant and see how that flies with what you’re saying–by saying “reclaiming fatherhood”–i wasn’t exactly thinking of gender so much as violence. i was thinking of all the little girls who’ve been raped, of all the little boys who got their asses kicked, of all the little little kids who have gotten ignored, pushed too hard, or in some way violated. i see how these actions are intimatly connected with gender–but as you listed off the actions of motherhood, i was thinking of the actions of fatherhood, you know? So by saying “reclaiming fatherhood”, i wasn’t necessarily taking the next step and saying “reclaiming masculinity”, but rather eliminating the actions that are so often fatherhood and replacing them with different actions. you know? i think that i got into your post where you were sort of disconnecting the gender of motherhood by concentrating more on the actions of motherhood…

  7. 7 vegankid May 18th, 2006 at 11:44 am

    bfp - yeah, i understood and feel what you were saying. I think its great that there is a movement out there that is reclaiming the positive role of fatherhood. It is something that is SO needed, for all the reasons you stated. I wasn’t trying to imply that you were talking about reclaiming masculinity (or about that Father’s Rights movement). I was mostly just going off on a late night tangent sparked by your words.

    I was talking more about theory. Asking what fatherhood and motherhood mean if we do strip them of their gender classifications. Not that that is an easy goal considering the long hystory of gendered violence that is so intimately connected to ‘fatherhood’. Hell, i’m not so sure its a goal at all. But if we do that, is there still a difference between positive fatherhood and motherhood? If so, what are they? I’m not trying to imply there isn’t. I am honestly struggling with the idea and sincerely asking the question.

  8. 8 Marla York Nov 12th, 2008 at 8:35 pm

    z5lnckkwn1bbzn61

Leave a Reply




Close
E-mail It